March 7, 1983
To the Congress of the United States:
I am transmitting to the Congress today legislation entitled, ``The Enterprise Zone Employment
and Development Act of 1983.'' This legislation will provide for the creation of meaningful jobs
within the private sector and the long-term revitalization of our Nation's most depressed areas. It
is offered as one element of a comprehensive jobs package intended to attack unemployment,
including such other elements as supplemental unemployment benefits, tax credits for hiring the
long-term unemployed, a summer youth program, and additional funds for job training and
relocation assistance.
In my January 25 State of the Union message, I indicated that we would reintroduce Enterprise
Zone legislation in the 98th Congress. While this legislation carries forward the tax and regulatory
relief measures of our earlier proposal in the 97th Congress, it contains several important
additions which reflect the combined wisdom of the growing coalition supporting this idea,
including the ideas of the small business community, State and local officials, labor organizations
and the many members of Congress who studied and debated our earlier legislation. We are
confident that the net result is strong, farsighted legislation designed to unleash the creative
energies of our free market economy in our most distressed urban areas. In these difficult days of
high unemployment, the legislation is drafted to be of direct, primary benefit to disadvantaged
workers and the long-term unemployed.
The high level of success experienced by the dozen or so State and local Enterprise Zone
programs is very encouraging. Prompt Federal action is warranted to bolster State and local
efforts, and it is in that spirit that I urge the early enactment of this legislation.
The Concept of Enterprise Zones
The Enterprise Zone program will improve the private sector's ability to provide new employment
opportunities, and in turn, urban regeneration. It creates a productive free market environment in
economically depressed areas by reducing taxes, regulations and other government burdens on
economic activity. The removal of these burdens will create and expand economic opportunity
within the zone areas, allowing business firms and entrepreneurs to create jobs -- particularly for
disadvantaged workers -- and expand economic activities.
Enterprise Zones are a fresh approach for promoting economic growth in the inner cities. The old
approach relied on heavy government subsidies and central planning. A prime example was the
Model Cities program of the 1960s, which concentrated government programs, subsidies and
regulations in specific, depressed urban areas. The Enterprise Zone approach would remove
government barriers, freeing individuals to create, produce and earn their own wages and
profits.
Mindful of the need to control public expenditures, Enterprise Zones require no Federal
appropriations other than necessary administrative expenses. Of course, states and cities have the
option of allocating existing Federal funds for their Enterprise Zones if they desire, or to
appropriate additional funds of their own for such zones.
Enterprise Zones are more than just a Federal initiative. State and local contributions to these
zones will be critically important in the competitive, Federal designation of zones, and probably
determine whether individual zones succeed or fail. In keeping with Constitutional requirements
of federalism, State and local governments retain broad flexibility to develop the contributions to
their zones most suitable to local conditions and preferences.
The Elements of Enterprise Zones
The Enterprise Zone program includes four basic elements:
-- Tax reduction at the Federal, State and local levels to lessen the economic impediments to
business investment and employment.
-- Regulatory relief at the Federal, State and local levels to reduce costly burdens which are
unnecessary to legitimate health and safety concerns.
-- New efforts to improve local services, including experimentation with private alternatives to
provide those services.
-- Neighborhood involvement so that local residents participate in the economic success of their
zones. For example, resident owned Enterprise Zone businesses might provide local services
which were previously monopolized by government.
By combining all these elements we will create the right economic environment for our Nation's
depressed areas.
The Structure of the Enterprise Zone Program
Title I of the Act describes the program's structure and how the zones will be established.
The initial designation or establishment of each zone will depend on local leadership and initiative.
To obtain the Federal incentives for Enterprise Zones, State and local governments must nominate
eligible areas to the Secretary of HUD.
As defined by the Act, eligible areas include all UDAG eligible jurisdictions which have significant
unemployment, poverty or population loss. Based on these criteria, currently more than 2,000
cities, rural areas and Indian reservations qualify. The Enterprise Zone program is a potential
source of economic assistance to distressed areas of all types, shapes and sizes, all across the
country.
The Secretary of HUD will be authorized to designate up to 75 zones over a three-year period.
The actual number designated will depend on the number and quality of the applications.
Federal designation of nominated zones is not automatic. The Secretary of HUD will evaluate the
various applications on a competitive basis, choosing the best applications for the limited number
of Federal designations authorized. The key criterion in this competitive process will be the nature
and strength of the State and local efforts to remove government burdens and to revitalize
Enterprise Zone areas.
Thus, the Federal evaluation of State and local contributions will be highly flexible and not
prescriptive. In this regard, the Secretary of HUD will not insist upon any particular item of tax
and regulatory relief. A weakness of State and local incentives in one area, such as tax relief,
could be offset by greater strength in another area such as regulatory relief.
Each Enterprise Zone will last for the period chosen by the nominating State and local
governments. The Federal incentives will apply to an approved zone for this entire period, up to a
maximum of 20 years plus a 4-year, phase-out period.
The Federal Incentives of the Enterprise Zone Program
Title II of the Act describes the Federal Tax incentives applying within Enterprise Zones, which
include:
The cost of the Enterprise Zone tax package should be minimal given the small amount of tax
revenue presently generated in Enterprise Zones. Moreover, as the Enterprise Zone concept
succeeds, the tax revenue attendant to increased economic activity should offset the tax losses in
the initial years.
Title III of the Act describes the Federal regulatory relief applying within Enterprise Zones. Under
these provisions, State and local governments may request relief for their Enterprise Zones from
any Federal regulation, unless it would directly violate a requirement imposed by statute. There is
no authority for any Federal regulatory relief within an Enterprise Zone without a request for such
relief from both the State and local governments.
This regulatory relief authority expressly does not apply, however, to regulations designed to
protect any person against discrimination because of race, color, religion, sex, marital status,
national origin, age or handicap. It also does not cover any regulation whose relaxation would
likely present a significant risk to the public safety, including environmental pollution. The
minimum wage law would not be covered by this authority because it is specifically imposed and
spelled out by statute.
The Role of State and Local Governments
While these Federal incentives are substantial, strong State and local contributions to the zones
will be necessary for the program to succeed.
These contributions can be from each of the four basic categories noted earlier: tax relief;
regulatory relief; improved local services; and increased participation by neighborhood
organizations. More traditional urban efforts, such as job training, minority business assistance or
infrastructure grants, can also be contributed to the zone. Once again, consistent with the
Administration's policy of restoring the Constitutional principle of federalism, the Federal
government will not dictate to State and local governments what they must contribute to the
zones.
The State and local contributions to the zones need not be costly. For example, regulatory relief,
service improvements through privatization, and private sector involvement all entail no budgetary
cost. Finally, as with the Federal tax relief, the cost of State and local tax relief should be modest
because of the little economic activity currently existing in potential Enterprise Zone areas. State
and local expenditures would be reduced as individuals who formerly received government aid are
employed in the zone.
The legislation I am sending you today is based on the work of many Members from both sides of
the aisle. I encourage these innovative individuals to work for early, bipartisan passage of this
legislation.
More than government expenditures and subsidies, residents of economically-depressed areas
need opportunities. This is the focus of the Enterprise Zone program. The program will identify
and remove government barriers to entrepreneurs who can create jobs and economic growth. It
will spark the latent talents and abilities already in existence in our Nation's most depressed areas.
The success of State Enterprise Zones confirms that the concept deserves to be given a chance to
work on the Federal level.
Ronald Reagan
The White House,
March 7, 1983.
The Federal tax reductions applying to Enterprise Zones are substantial. They include reductions
for employers, employees, entrepreneurs and investors. They include incentives for attracting
venture capital, hiring workers, particularly disadvantaged workers, and starting and building up
new businesses. They include the reduction, and in some cases elimination, of corporate income
taxes, individual income taxes and capital gains taxes.